Survey | KRG Hospitality

AI-generated image of a person carrying takeout bags from restaurant to their motorcycle

September 6, 2024by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

Is Demand for Delivery Down?

Is Demand for Delivery Down?

by David Klemt

I have done this. Cargo straps required.

Not too long ago, it seemed as delivery was going to overtake people’s desire to enjoy a restaurant in person, but that trend may be on a downward swing.

At first, this trend made perfect sense, for obvious reasons. For a while, the best way for consumers to enjoy their favorite restaurants and show support was to order delivery.

Rideshare companies jumped on delivery, as did several platforms. When guests were able to visit restaurants in person freely, delivery had become a habit for many of them. In fact, ordering delivery had become the de facto method of engaging with restaurants for a not-insignificant percentage of people.

However, operators and their teams weren’t shy about exposing their delivery “partners.” I think it’s fair to describe the fees operators were being charged by some of these partners as outrageous.

When the public found out about these fees, they didn’t sit well. Takeout, carryout, takeaway, order for pickup… Whatever your preferred nomenclature, people began seeing it as superior to delivery. This shift in consumer behavior was driven by a desire to support their favorite restaurants.

Of course, there are other factors that affected people’s move away from delivery. I’m confident in saying that most of us who have ordered delivery at some point in the last couple of years has experienced at least one of several downsides.

However, has delivery really fallen out of favor? Have takeout or drive-up pickup actually been passing up delivery?

Datassential’s 2024 Midyear Trends Report has some insights that can answer those questions. You can (and should) check it out for yourself here.

The State of Takeout and Delivery

To obtain a snapshot of the state of the performance of delivery and takeout, Datassential conducted a survey in May of this year. The F&B intelligence platform surveyed 400 US operators and more than 1,500 US consumers.

According to Datassential, nearly half of restaurant operators reported increases in guests dining in person at their restaurants.

Perhaps more telling, however, is that Datassential’s survey reveals that half of restaurants aren’t even offering delivery. I don’t know the breakdown of operators who once offered delivery and stopped doing so versus operators who never offered delivery.

What I do know is that there are, as I alluded to up top, many reasons for people to eschew delivery. Chief among these are cost, and the condition of the order when it arrives to the guest.

On the operator side, cost is once again a consideration, as are negative reviews and complaints. More than one study has shown that operators often get the blame when a third party botches an element of the delivery. These complaints can include food being delivered lukewarm or cold, parts of the delivery missing, or the wrong items being delivered to someone.

But, again, is demand for delivery slipping?

Per Datassential’s report, takeout and catering are outpacing the growth of delivery for US operators. Almost 40 percent of operators who participated in Datassential’s survey reported an increase in frequency for takeout and catering orders. In comparison, just 20 percent of respondents ordered an increase in delivery order.

Just eight percent of operators indicated a decrease in takeout and delivery. In fact, the greatest decrease impacts catering (14 percent), according to Datassential’s report.

Takeaway

Delivery, simply put, doesn’t work for every operator or every concept. Moreover, it looks like consumer desire for takeout is on a greater upswing in contrast to delivery.

For concepts that succeed with delivery, it’s imperative that operators control the process rather than cede to third parties, in my opinion.

The best way forward will vary from business to business. Operators and their teams need to be ruthless the quality, consistency, accuracy, and value of all orders, whether placed in person, for takeout, or for delivery. Further, when it comes to takeout and delivery, the ordering process must be convenient.

What’s clear is that every operator needs to dive into their data, determine how guests prefer to order from their restaurant, and pursue those preferences to enhance the guest experience.

Image: Microsoft Designer

Book Below to Setup a 30-Minute Complimentary Discovery Call and Request for Proposal.

An Xbox One controller sitting on a Scorpion Gaming mouse pad

August 30, 2024by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

Game On: Datassential’s Midyear Report

Game On: Datassential’s Midyear Trends Report

by David Klemt

Brought to you by Xbox, Scorpion Gaming, and cool photography.

The 2024 Midyear Trends Report released by Datassential earlier this month contains an intriguing revelation that savvy operators can leverage.

There is, of course, interesting and useful information throughout. After all, Datassential conducted a survey of 1,500-plus US consumers, along with 400 US foodservice operators.

Surveying nearly 2,000 people is going to garner some helpful insights.

For example, we know that many people are concerned with their nutrition. Along with that comes reading nutrition labels. However, US consumers appear to throw that behavior to the wayside when dining out.

According to Datassential’s survey results, 62 percent of consumers in the US read the nutrition labels on new items before selecting them for purchase at grocery stores. But nearly that same percentage of consumers, 58 percent, don’t consider diets or nutrition when choosing where they’re going to eat.

What that says to me is that people still viewing dining out as a treat or an occasion. Most people, when treating themselves and others, see it as an escape. An escape from the stresses of work, of life, and from eating “boring” foods.

People are still driven to leave home to gather, socialize, and have fun. And restaurants and bars still play a major role in meeting those needs and desires.

Negative and fear-mongering stories may be getting all the clicks, but Datassential’s findings are much less on the doom-and-gloom side of the equation. Per their midyear report, nearly 90 percent of US restaurant operators have seen increases in traffic (46 percent) or had their traffic remain the same (42 percent) so far this year. Just 12 percent of operators reported decreases in traffic, according to Datassential.

Game On

Now, let’s look at the data in this report that really caught my attention.

The Datassential report reveals that 61 percent of survey respondents play video games. Citing Entertainment Software Association data, close to 200 million Americans are gamers. Going further, gaming spans all ages. Last year, gamers spent well over $50 billion on this particular hobby. MarketWatch claims even combined, the global sports and movie industries don’t outperform video games financially.

Of all respondents to the Datassential survey, a quarter aren’t gamers, and 15 percent “used to” play video games. That latter group consists mainly of Gen Xers. And, hey, fair enough—some people don’t enjoy or have time for video games.

In contrast, however, 23 percent of survey respondents label themselves “avid gamers.” Gen Z, Millennials, and men make up the majority of this group of consumers.

Almost 40 percent (38%) classify themselves as “casual.” This group consists mainly of Gen X, Gen Z, and women.

Alright, so…what does this have to do with restaurant operators? Well, gamers spent $57 billion just on video games. Per Datassential, 45 percent of survey respondents have made F&B purchases after consuming video game-related ads or content. This is true of 63 percent of US Gen Z consumers, and 56 percent of US Millennials.

These stats tell me that gaming pays not just for console manufacturers and game producers, but also for F&B operators. It would seem to me, then, that operators with concepts that can leverage video games in an authentic manner should give strong consideration to doing so.

So, game on?

Image: Jose Gil on Unsplash

An AI-generated image of a person holding a stopwatch at a restaurant table while guests read the menu

August 12, 2024by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

Eliminate Hesitation: Streamline Your Menu

Eliminate Hesitation: Streamline Your Menu

by David Klemt

That’s an interesting stopwatch layout. Also, we don’t recommend sitting with guests and timing them as they review your menu.

Operators should develop an understanding of the concept of the paradox of choice to understand how American guests make menu item selections.

So, allow me a crash course in this psychological concept. There are two prevailing components to the paradox of choice. One is that the more options one has, the less satisfaction they’ll feel upon making a choice. The other is that when presented with an overwhelming number of choices, also known as “choice overload,” people often just fall back to their usual choice rather than trying something new.

A quick note: The paradox of choice isn’t the same as the fallacy of choice. That concept relates to presenting someone with limited, extreme choices to drive them to ignore all of the other choices they could consider and select.

Understanding the paradox of choice will help an operator tackle a key task: streamlining their menus.

A survey from US Foods earlier this year contains quite a few intriguing revelations. Among their findings, one stands head and shoulders above the rest, at least to me: Almost 80 percent of Americans find deciding what they want to order at a restaurant difficult. Further, one factor outpaces all others when it comes to difficulty choosing.

Hence, my explanation of the paradox of choice at the top of this article.

Menus are too Big

There are two key factors making it difficult for Americans to choose what to order at a restaurant. Nearly a quarter of respondents—23 percent—indicate that they’re simply picky people. Alright, fair enough.

But the main factor, unsurprisingly, is that restaurants are presenting guests with too many options. That’s according to 54 percent of survey respondents. Quick math tells me that’s more than double the picky eaters.

Another 15 percent of US Foods survey respondents, however, say they have no trouble deciding what they want to order. Eight percent say they’re indifferent, which is an entirely different problem. A guest who’s indifferent to the restaurant and menu isn’t an engaged guest, and that’s not going to inspire loyalty and repeat visits.

Of course, no operator can please everyone, and some people aren’t going to be blown away no matter how good the food, drinks, and service can be.

So, does this mean that Americans are indecisive, facing paralysis whenever a servers asks for their order? Well…maybe. We have a lot going on, and “overwhelmed” would describe many of my fellow Americans right now.

However, the real culprit is menu size. In trying to please and retain guests, some operators are loathe to shrink their menus.

Most KRG clients can attest to the following: the president of our agency, Doug Radkey, prefers a smaller, streamlined menu. In fact, he prefers menus not pass the 25-item mark. Given his druthers, Radkey favors 12 to 15 items.

There are several reasons for this preference. Chief among these are controlling and reducing labor and food costs. (Radkey prefers to control costs rather than cut them, realistically.) Other reasons are less strain on the back of house, easier cross-utilization of ingredients, consistency, and reduced ticket times.

We can also add improving guest satisfaction to the list. On average, an American restaurant guest takes nine minutes to decide what they want to order at a restaurant. Streamline and shrink the menu, and this number should fall, while satisfaction rises.

Anyone should see that a smaller, sharper menu represents wins across the board.

AI image generator: Microsoft Designer

Bar or restaurant worker on phone in alleyway with graffiti

March 29, 2024by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

Hey, Bartenders: Tales Wants Your Input

Hey, Bartenders: Tales of the Cocktail Wants Your Input

by David Klemt

The Tales of the Cocktail Foundation and the IWSR would like bartenders around the world to complete a survey for a research project.

Attendees of the 2023 event in New Orleans may be familiar with this initiative. Entering into what TOTCF would like to be a long-term partnership, the IWSR, Drinks Market Analysis is collaborating on the project.

As a refresher, the IWSR is known throughout the global industry as the standard in beverage alcohol data collection and research. For an idea of the insights the industry intelligence agency can provide, check out their 2024 beverage trends e-book.

So, what does this have to do with bartenders? Well, it’s simple, really.

At its core, Tales of the Cocktail is about a key relationship within the hospitality industry. Namely, bartenders and beverage brands. Traditionally, that has meant spirits brands. However, this relationship now certainly includes zero-proof brands alongside their alcoholic spirits, beer, and wine counterparts.

Given how important this inextricable connection is to the industry as a whole, it’s logical that the TOTCF is interested in understanding it on a deeper level. This is where bartenders (and bar and restaurant staff) enter into the TOTCF-IWSR partnership.

All Tales needs from bartenders across the globe is five to ten minutes of their time. That’s as long as it should take for bartenders to complete a survey hosted by the IWSR.

Anyone interested in participating—and it’s not a huge ask, in my opinion—should click this link to learn more. However, for those who require a bit more incentive than just helping Tales, there are two $100 Amazon gift cards up for grabs.

Spend a few minutes, maybe win a prize. Sounds good to me.

Additional Details

The main focus of Tales has leaned toward bartenders. But, as stated above, this survey isn’t exclusive to that role.

As the rules state, other bar and restaurant team members may participate and take the survey as well.

Bear in mind, however, that this survey closes soon. Anyone who wants to contribute to this research project has only until April 8 to do so.

Further, the findings of this survey will be shared at this year’s Tales of the Cocktail, which takes place from July 21 to July 26. Tickets go on sale on Monday, May 13, also known as World Cocktail Day. Mark your calendars!

Per the IWSR’s survey page, the survey is anonymous; answers aren’t tied to a participant’s personal information. Further, the IWSR’s analysis of answers will be at the group level, not individual.

If this all sounds good, please follow this link to participate: https://talesofthecocktail.org/iwsr-drinks-market-analysis/

Cheers!

Image: Gina Santangelo on Unsplash

A cheeseburger with chicken patties, pizza, and steak on it

March 25, 2024by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

Which Chains are America’s Favorites?

NRN & Technomic Identify America’s Favorite Chains

by David Klemt

Alright, which one of you maniacs out there is going to make this AI-generated chicken-patty-pizza-steak burger a reality and put it on your menu?

Toward the beginning of 2024, Nation’s Restaurant News collaborated with Technomic to identify America’s favorite restaurant chains.

To my understanding, this is the first such partnership between the independent foodservice publication and the foodservice intelligence platform.

Providing more than just a glimpse into America’s favorite chains, the rankings span several categories. For instance, the partnership between NRN and Technomic reveals the top QSRs, along with the country’s favorite fast-casual, family-style, and miscale restaurants.

However, the top three chains across more granular categories are also identified. Examples include America’s favorite chicken, pizza, burger, and Mexican restaurants.

In fact, I’m going to kick things off with the more specific, specialized categories. Then, I’ll move into the broader segments.

That said, I encourage you to review NRN‘s article revealing America’s favorite midscale, casual, QSR, etc. restaurants for yourself. Written by Joanna Fantozzi, the piece is full of valuable insights beyond simple rankings.

Further, you may find it interesting to compare these rankings to the results of BrandVue’s Most Loved Eating Out Brands 2023 report, which we reviewed here.

Cheers to NRN and Technomic! Here’s to hoping that this becomes an annual release.

Beverage or Snack

Tropical Smoothie Cafe
Smoothie King
Jamba

Burger

Culver’s
In-N-Out
Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburger

Chicken

Chick-fil-A
Jollibee
Raising Cane’s

Italian (FSR)

Carrabba’s Italian Grill
Maggiano’s Little Italy
Mellow Mushroom

Mexican

Chuy’s Tex-Mex
Torchy’s Tacos
Moe’s Southwest Grill

Pizza

Papa Murphy’s
Marco’s Pizza
Cici’s Pizza

Sandwich

Jersey Mike’s Subs
Newk’s Eatery
Jason’s Deli

Steak

Ruth’s Chris Steak House
Fleming’s Prime Steakhouse
Longhorn Steakhouse

Varied Menu

Seasons 52
Bahama Breeze Island Grille
Cooper’s Hawk

QSR

Dutch Bros Coffee
Topical Smoothie Cafe
Smoothie King
Cold Stone Creamery
Chik-fil-A

Fast Casual

Jersey Mike’s Subs
Newk’s Eatery
Jason’s Deli
McAlister’s Deli
Sweetgreen

Family Style

First Watch
Cracker Barrel
Golden Corral

Casual

Seasons 52
Bahama Breeze Island Grille
Bonefish Grill
Longhorn Steakhouse
Cooper’s Hawk

Midscale

First Watch
Cracker Barrel
Golden Corral
Shoney’s
Black Bear Diner

Favorite Chains: Overall

Ruth’s Chris Steak House
Season 52
Dutch Bros Coffee
Fleming’s Prime Steakhouse
Bahama Breeze Island Grille
Longhorn Steakhouse
Cooper’s Hawk
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
The Capital Grille
Smoothie King

When it comes to this list of the top-ten favorite chain restaurants, Technomic data scores a number of crucial insights.

Click here to see how each of these industry leaders ranked in:

Service and hospitality
Unit appearance and ambience
F&B
Convenience and takeout
Value

Image: Shutterstock. Disclaimer: This image was generated by an Artificial Intelligence (AI) system.

March 15, 2024by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

What are You Changing in 2024?

What are You Changing in Your Restaurant or Bar in 2024?

by David Klemt

More fun with AI-generated images. That’s quite the busy bar setup.

Toward the end of last year, Nation’s Restaurant News identified what changes operators chose to make after analyzing their operational data.

The publication surveyed hundreds of operators about how data drove their decisions. This survey was an element of their year-end report, Market Leader Report: The Data-driven Restaurant.

As one would imagine, this report focuses on data collection, analysis, and usage. However, NRN‘s report doesn’t just address the importance of data collection in the F&B space. Rather, they seek to understand if operators are collecting the “right” data; whether they can optimize the data they collect; what metrics they’re tracking; and how they’re acting on all that data.

Simply put, it’s an important report addressing a topic crucial to today’s restaurant and bar operations. Those who want their own copy of The Data-driven Restaurant can download it free here.

While entire report is valuable, the focus of this article is one question and the answers provided. Below, to provide context, is a breakdown of the survey respondents.

The Who

Most of the respondents identified as independent restaurant operators.

Indie: 37 percent
Chain (franchisee): 21 percent
Chain (company owned): 18 percent
Multi-concept: 15 percent
Single-site operator: 6 percent
HQ or brand level of foodservice company: 3 percent

By a slim margin, most survey respondents categorized their restaurants as full service or casual dining.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the fewest respondents operate in the upscale or fine dining category.

Full service / casual dining: 30 percent
Fast casual: 28 percent
Quick service: 20 percent
Midscale / family dining: 15 percent
Upscale / fine dining: 7 percent

The What

So, what question caught our attention at KRG Hospitality?

“In the past 12 months, which initiatives did your organization undertake after analyzing data?”

NRN conducted this survey in November 2023. Not surprisingly, respondents mostly made changes to their menus after reviewing their data. Streamlining menus and adjusting prices were two of the biggest operational trends last year, as many operators are no doubt well aware.

That theory is supported by the survey results. Below, the top four answers to the question above.

Changed menu prices (48 percent)
Removed items from or added items to our menu (47 percent)
Improved the way we trained our staff (26 percent)
Adjusted our loyalty program’s rewards and/or incentives (24 percent)

Honestly, it’s heartening to see that training is among the top-three data-driven actions operators took last year. And, of course, it’s not shocking that the menu was the focus of the most attention. Streamlining is an effective way to reduce food and labor costs. Further, pricing is always (please excuse the pun) on the menu.

Our question is: What changes, if any, do you plan to implement this year now that we’re headed into Q3?

The What: The Sequel

If the menu received the most attention after operators reviewed their data, what received the least?

Well, it appears marketing fell to the wayside, along with the kitchen. The following are the bottom four answers to the question in the section above:

A/B tested marketing campaigns and increased ROI (6 percent)
Changed specs on our kitchen equipment or technology (10 percent)
Identified lapsed customers and marketed to them (11 percent)
Increased throughput in our kitchen during peak periods (13 percent)

Now, I’ll concede that one marketing action found itself in the middle of the pack when it came to this survey question. Upon analyzing their data, 18 percent of respondents identified new potential guests and marketed to those people.

Still, in comparison to making changes to menus, the fewest respondents took marketing action or made changes to the kitchen directly.

Does this mean that menu changes have the greatest impact on guests and ROI? Well, that’s possible. However, I think something else is at play.

Personally, I think collecting data is the easy part. At this point, most platforms serving our industry are collecting data for operators.

But tracking the correct metrics, analyzing the associated data, and knowing what to do after analyzing said data? That’s difficult. It can be overwhelming, which is why it’s so important to build and implement the proper tech stack for a specific concept. This is why one of the services we offer our clients is tech-stack development.

Further, the tech stack needs to be built around an operator and their leadership team. If nobody knows how to use it or what to do with the data they’re collecting, it’s useless.

Image: Shutterstock. Disclaimer: This image was generated by an Artificial Intelligence (AI) system.

Aerial photograph of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, at night

February 7, 2024by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

Best and Worst Cities for Servers

Service Wins and Woes: Best and Worst Cities for Servers

by David Klemt

A recent survey from gaming industry site Casinos.US identifies the 25 best and two-dozen worst cities for servers in America.

I can share two details about the methodology that Casinos.US employed.

One, they surveyed 2,000 current and former hospitality professionals. And two, they were asked to rate the overall rudeness of their guests on a scale of one to ten. One is the kindest, ten is the rudest.

Further, I can share that the average rudeness of guests being served in the US is 4.9 out of ten. Unfortunately, the three worst cities on the Casinos.US list rank between 7.0 and 7.6 on the rudeness scale. In fact, 22 of the 24 worst cities come in at 5.0 or above.

No city is perfect. The best of the best earns a score of 2.0, with the next best hitting a 3.0. Still, not bad at all.

Sadly, 45 percent of respondents reported finding themselves interacting with rude guests at least twice per day. As far as the worst of the worst, respondents identified “older adults” as the rudest, and Sunday as the day of the week with the most incidents. Do with that information as you will.

There are two sides to the coin, of course. Impressively, 24 percent of respondents “rarely” encounter rudeness from guests. Even better, 28 percent don’t expect to come across rude guests on a daily basis at work. So, there’s some hope out there.

To review the results of this survey for yourself, click here.

The Worst

Alright, let’s get it out of the way. Below, the worst cities in America for servers, according to Casinos.us.

To the right, their rudeness score. Again, the score is out of ten, with ten being the absolute worst.

Washington, DC (4.9)
Orlando, Florida (4.9)
San Antonio, Texas (5.0)
Sacramento, California (5.0)
Columbus, Ohio (5.0)
Buffalo, New York (5.0)
Houston, Texas (5.1)
St. Louis, Missouri (5.1)
Atlanta, Georgia (5.1)
Louisville, Kentucky (5.3)
Miami, Florida (5.3)
Nashville, Tennessee (5.4)
New York, New York (5.4)
Phoenix, Arizona (5.6)
Detroit, Michigan (5.7)
San Diego, California (5.8)
Las Vegas, Nevada (5.8)
New Orleans, Louisiana (5.8)
Milwaukee, Wisconsin (6.0)
Providence, Rhode Island (6.3)
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma (6.3)
Jacksonville, Florida (7.0)
Cincinnati, Ohio (7.0)
Virginia Beach, Virginia (7.6)

This list, if accurate, leaves me with one question: What’s going on, Virginia Beach? Sheesh. Calm down—your side of ranch isn’t that important, I promise.

It’s tempting to label this a tourist issue. Well over 10 million people—nearly 20 million in 2019—visit Virginia Beach annually.

And, hey, look at the rest of the list; it’s loaded with destination cities that draw millions upon millions of tourists each year.

However, when you look at the list of the best cities for servers below you’ll find more destination cities.

The Best

Now that we know the worst, let’s check out the best.

The cities below rank the lowest as far as rude behavior from guests.

Dallas, Texas (4.8)
Minneapolis, Minnesota (4.8)
Boston, Massachusetts (4.8)
Birmingham, Alabama (4.8)
Salt Lake City, Utah (4.8)
Los Angeles, California (4.7)
San Francisco, California (4.7)
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (4.7)
Raleigh, North Carolina (4.6)
Riverside, California (4.5)
Kansas City, Missouri (4.5)
Seattle, Washington (4.5)
Charlotte, North Carolina (4.4)
Richmond, Virginia (4.3)
Cleveland, Ohio (4.3)
Indianapolis, Indiana (4.2)
Chicago, Illinois (4.1)
Denver, Colorado (4.1)
Portland, Oregon (4.0)
Tampa, Florida (3.8)
Hartford, Connecticut (3.8)
Austin, Texas (3.8)
Baltimore, Maryland (3.7)
Memphis, Tennessee (3.0)
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (2.0)

Philly may be the City of Brotherly Love but the Steel City, Pittsburgh, is the best for servers in terms of guest behavior. At least, according to Casinos.US.

If you live in one of the cities above, go out to bars and restaurants, and aren’t a jerk to your servers, congratulations on being a decent person.

Takeaway

Let’s say you’re an owner, operator, or leadership team member. And let’s say you operate or work in one of the cities above, whether the best or worst.

If your service team routinely on edge, regularly upset, find out why. Leaders look out for their teams and strive to provide a healthy work environment.

I’m not saying you need to get into the details of their personal lives. What I am saying is that if there are issues in the workplace, you need to get to the bottom of them. More importantly, you then need to engage the team and get their feedback.

How do they want guest issues handled by the leadership team? Are their problematic regulars who need to be “fired” to protect the team? Some guests simply aren’t worth the revenue and tips in exchange for the emotional and mental distress they’re inflicting on the team.

That is, however, something that must be discussed. Most importantly, when the feedback is taken into account and a procedure is put in place, leadership must adhere to it and act accordingly. Any deviation will result in a loss of trust, and that will decimate team morale even more quickly than an encounter with a rude guest.

Lose trust from your team, lose the business.

Image: Venti Views on Unsplash

February 6, 2024by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

Pizza Today Reveals Top New Cheeses

Pizza Today Reveals Top New Cheeses for 2024

by David Klemt

Pizza Today‘s informative 2024 Pizza Industry Trends Report is full of useful information, from top styles and toppings to new cheeses guests can choose.

Two weeks ago we did a deep dive into the top eleven pizza styles going into 2024, per Pizza Today. Click here to read that article.

Last week we checked out what the pizza publication had to say about top pizza styles by region. Additionally, we looked at the top toppings nationally and regionally. You can read that article here.

Now, we’re going to talk about what Pizza Today has learned about the top cheeses operators are putting on their menus.

Top Pizza Styles, Nationally and Regionally

Before we jump into the cheeses, a quick recap of the top pizza styles in America.

New York
Traditional American
Sicilian
Deep Dish
Neapolitan / Napoletana
Chicago Thin / Tavern-style
Detroit
Grandma
California / American Artisan
NEOpolitan / Neo-Neapolitan and Chicago Thick (tie)

And now, the top trending pizza styles.

Detroit
Deep Dish and Grandma (tie)
Sicilian
New York
Chicago Thin

Finally, the top pizza styles by region. For a more detailed explanation of each region, click here.

The West

New York Style
Traditional America
California/American Artisan
Sicilian
Neapolitan

The South

New York Style
Traditional America
Sicilian
Deep Dish
Neapolitan

The Midwest

Traditional America
Chicago Thin
New York Style
Deep Dish
Detroit

The Northeast

New York Style
Sicilian
Traditional America
Neapolitan
Grandma

Top Pizza Toppings, Nationally and Regionally

We’re almost to the cheeses. First, a recap of the most popular items to put on top of cheese.

Well, unless we’re talking a stuffed pizza. Click here and scroll to Deep Dish to see what I mean.

Now, the top toppings across the US.

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Extra Cheese
Bacon
Chicken
Onion
Red/Green Bell Pepper
Ham
Black Olives
Meatballs
Canadian Bacon
Jalapenos
Pineapple
Beef
Basil
Banana Peppers
Fresh garlic
Tomatoes
Spinach

Below, how toppings break down regionally.

The West

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Chicken
Bacon

The South

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Extra cheese
Bacon

The Midwest

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Bacon
Onion

The Northeast

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Extra cheese
Bacon

Top “New” Cheeses

Okay, so we’ve reviewed top pizza styles. We’ve done a recap for toppings.

So, what are some of the top “new” cheeses going onto those pizza styles and being covered in all those toppings?

It may seem odd the refer to the cheeses below as “new.” In this context, “new” means, “not mozzarella” or “not provolone,” for the most part. Or, if you’re in St. Louis, “not Provel.”

Ricotta
Cheddar
Fresh Mozzarella
Goat Cheese
Parmigiano Crema
Cotija Cheese
Scamorza
Vegan Cheese
Blue Cheese
Feta

Guests love personalization, and they love the opportunity to try new foods and new takes on foods they know.

Scamorza

For the most part, you’re likely familiar with all the cheeses above. However, if you’re like me, you may be unfamiliar with scamorza. If that’s the case, I looked into it for both of us.

Like mozzarella, scamorza is made from either stretched cow or water buffalo milk cheese curds. This cheese originates from Italy and comes in two styles: scamorza bianca or and scamorza affumicata. The former is white or natural, while the latter is smoked and brownish in appearance.

Further, bianca is a mild, somewhat sweet cheese. Affumicata, being smoked, delivers a more savory and, as one would expect, smoky flavor.

Vegan Cheese

If you aren’t offering vegan or plant-based cheese for your pizzas, you may not know what brands to use.

Well, don’t worry. I’ve also done some legwork into this topic.

Brands to check out are Violife, Diya, Chao, and Miyoko’s. As plant-based alternatives become more commonplace and expected by guests, I expect more commercial vegan-friendly cheeses to become available. Perhaps we’ll see some at this year’s National Restaurant Association Show.

Image: Pablo Pacheco on Unsplash

January 30, 2024by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

Top Pizza Styles & Toppings by Region

Top Pizza Styles & Toppings by Region

by David Klemt

That’s one way to pick up a slice of pizza…

Now that we know the top 11 pizza styles in North America thanks to Pizza Today, let’s see how they break down by region.

Unfortunately, they don’t include regions throughout Canada in their trends report. However, the information is still incredibly valuable.

Pizza Today has put a lot of effort into their 2024 Pizza Industry Trends Report. So, make sure to click this link and check it out for yourself.

Before we jump into the regional breakdown, let’s check out which pizza toppings lead the way across the nation. As you’ll see later, while many regions follow national trends, they also deviate in notable ways.

If you read last week’s article, you already know which pizza styles dominate North America. For those of you haven’t yet read that article, click here.

That said, here are the top 20 toppings in America.

Top Toppings: Nationwide

If you operate a pizzeria or pizza is a significant focus of your business, you probably know the number one topping.

The image at the top of this article is a hint.

Per Pizza Today, these are the top 20 toppings in the US:

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Extra Cheese
Bacon
Chicken
Onion
Red/Green Bell Pepper
Ham
Black Olives
Meatballs
Canadian Bacon
Jalapenos
Pineapple
Beef
Basil
Banana Peppers
Fresh garlic
Tomatoes
Spinach

Due to outright bias, I hope to see meatballs break into the top ten one of these days. That’s my number one topping.

Now that we’ve shared the top 20 toppings according to Pizza Today, let’s check out the regional breakdown.

The West

This region includes two subregions, Pacific and Mountain.

In alphabetical order, the Pacific states are Alaska, California, Hawaii, Oregon, and Washington. The Mountain region includes Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming.

So, if you’re in one of those 13 states, the info below is relevant to you.

Top Styles

New York Style
Traditional America
California/American Artisan
Sicilian
Neapolitan

Number three makes sense, given this region includes California. Otherwise, the West follows the top five pizza styles in the US rather closely.

Top Toppings

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Chicken
Bacon
Extra cheese
Black Olives
Onion
Jalapenos
Pineapple

In the West, the top three toppings are the same as the rest of the nation. However, chicken and bacon overtake extra cheese in the this region.

The South

Pizza Today divides the South into three subregions: East South Central, South Atlantic, and West South Central.

The former consists of Alabama, Kentucky, Mississippi, and Tennessee. The South Atlantic includes Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, Washington, D.C., and West Virginia. And West South Central is made up of Arkansas, Louisiana, Oklahoma, and Texas.

As you’ll see, the top five pizza styles in the South are the same as the top across the US. Further, the top five toppings in the region are also the same top five nationally. It isn’t until numbers six through ten that we encounter deviations.

Top Styles

New York Style
Traditional America
Sicilian
Deep Dish
Neapolitan

Top Toppings

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Extra cheese
Bacon
Onion
Chicken
Red/Green pepper
Beef
Ham

Beef is number 15 nationally, if you don’t want to scroll up and check for yourself.

The Midwest

The Midwest, per Pizza Today, is organized into two subregions. Those are East North Central and West North Central.

Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin make up the former. Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, and South Dakota are the states in the latter subregion.

Top Styles

As a proud Midwesterner, I’m happy to report that the region didn’t disappoint when it comes to the region’s top pizza styles.

Traditional America
Chicago Thin
New York Style
Deep Dish
Detroit

The argument that Chicago Thin (a.k.a. Chicago Tavern) rather than Deep Dish is the true Chicago pizza style is bolstered with these rankings.

Top Toppings

Pizza Today shares only five toppings for this region. Notably, extra cheese doesn’t make it in, kicked out by onion.

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Bacon
Onion

The Northeast

The Middle Atlantic and New England are the two subregions of the Northeast.

For their report, Pizza Today identifies New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania as the three Middle Atlantic states. New England is Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Vermont.

Top Style

Number five, given where it was reportedly created, isn’t a surprise.

In fact, the whole list makes sense:

New York Style
Sicilian
Traditional America
Neapolitan
Grandma

It’s also not a surprise that Deep Dish doesn’t make it into the Northeast’s top five pizza styles.

Top Toppings

Further, the top five of ten top toppings in the Northeast are the same nationally.

Pepperoni
Sausage
Mushroom
Extra cheese
Bacon
Chicken
Onion
Red/Green pepper
Meatballs
Banana Peppers

However, as you can see, meatballs (my favorite) and banana peppers break into the top ten in this region.

Takeaways

Obviously, there are more than just 20 toppings finding their way onto pizzas in the US. Pizza Today reports that birria, fig jam, hot honey, pasilla peppers, and pickled vegetables have earned their way onto menus in at least the past 12 months.

And when it comes the top 20 toppings, there’s nuance. For example, there are multiple styles of pepperoni and preparation, and the same holds true for sausage.

All this is to say the following: A blend of popular, traditional toppings along with the unexpected and new is likely a winning combination. This can include exotic ingredients, plant-based analogs, and international herbs and spices.

Remember, it’s pizza; it’s supposed to tempting and fun.

Image: Maksim Goncharenok on Pexels

November 21, 2023by David Klemt David Klemt No Comments

2023 State of the Menu: Datassential

2023 State of the Menu: Datassential

by David Klemt

The annual 2023 State of the Menu by Datassential includes an interesting metric to gauge restaurant recovery: menu size by segment.

Hosts Jack Li, Mike Kostyo, and Claire Conaghan discuss a handful of topics during this webinar. Host Li touches on food-forward cities at the beginning of this presentaiton. Kostyo shares some of the most innovative menu items out there right now. And Conaghan dives deep into menu trends.

Industry professionals interested in watching this webinar on demand can register to do so here.

There are a handful of metrics people are using to measure post-pandemic restaurant recovery. Labor is, of course, receiving a lot of attention. People are also tracking traffic, average check size, revenue, and profits.

One metric Datassential is keeping tabs on is menu size per restaurant segment. Additionally, they’re tracking each segment’s top-growing food and beverage items.

Notably, however, in tracking menu size, Conaghan focuses solely on food and non-alcohol beverage items, omitting catering and alcohol.

Chains vs. Independents

Starting things off, Conaghan addresses the overall menu size trend. That is, menus are noticeably smaller in comparison to pre-pandemic sizes.

Interestingly, chain restaurants don’t appear to be in any rush to move away from this trend. In fact, Conaghan notes that chains appear to be further reducing the size of their menus. This has been the trend over the past 12 months.

According to Conaghan, fine dining also seems to be happy to shrink their menus. Menu size shrunk the most among restaurants in this segment. In comparison, quick-service menu sizes decreased the least.

However, independent restaurant operators appear to be going in the opposite direction from their chain counterparts. In contrast, indies have been growing the size of their menus the past 12 months.

Menu Size by Segment

Fast Casual

Per Conaghan, the only segment to reach pre-pandemic menu size is fast casual. In fact, this category of restaurant is often exceeding pre-pandemic items-per-menu size.

This increase in menu size is attributable to operators “leaning into” core cuisine items. For example, sandwiches, Mexican entrees, and pizza.

However, the fastest-growing food item on fast-casual menus is the chicken wing. According to Conaghan, it’s easy for operators to innovate with chicken wings.

A restaurant doesn’t have chicken wings? All they have to do is add them, starting with simple preparations. If a restaurant does have chicken wings on the menu already, innovation is as simple as adding new flavors.

As far as the fastest-growing drink for fast-casual restaurants, it’s dessert beverages.

QSR, Casual Dining, and Midscale

These three segments are “very, very close” to reaching pre-pandemic menu sizes.

As midscale operators are likely very aware, this segment tends to have the largest menus. I wouldn’t be surprised, therefore, if a number of midscale concepts review their items per menu, their costs, and decide they can perform well with slightly smaller menus moving forward.

Unsurprisingly, chicken wings are the food item growing most quickly on QSR food menus. Oh, and barbecue chicken wings are the fastest-growing food item among casual dining restaurants.

Perhaps a bit more eyebrow-raising is the fastest-growing beverage type for QSRs: energy drinks. Boba and flavored iced teas are growing fastest on casual-dining drink menus.

For midscale restaurants, dessert samplers are the fastest-growing food items. Think “dessert charcuterie” when trying to picture a dessert platter. Another way to think about the dessert sampler is a static dessert cart with small bites of each dessert on the menu.

Fine Dining

Again, this segment is the furthest from pre-pandemic menu size. And, again, operators in this category seem happy with this trend.

An interesting note Conaghan makes about this segment is what many operators are using to fill out their menus: desserts. This is, she says, an area where fine dining can differentiate itself from other concepts.

Per Conaghan, bao, applesauce, and summer squash are growing the fastest on fine-dining food menus.

Now, I may have slipped into a fever dream during this portion of the Datassential webinar. Because unless I’m mistaken, the Shirley Temple has been identified as the fastest-growing beverage in the fine-dining space.

Pricing

Okay, so this segment of the 2023 State of the Menu webinar isn’t really a recovery metric.

However, it’s interesting, and something Jack Li says about chain restaurant pricing made me chuckle.

Most Expensive vs. Least Expensive

First, some straightforward data.

The following list identifies the five most-expensive ZIP codes for chain restaurant menu pricing. Anyone who wants the full list of 15 most-expensive ZIP codes can watch the webinar.

10036 (New York, NY)
96707 (Kapolei, HI)
98902 (Yakima, WA)
96815 (Honolulu, HI)
99503 (Anchorage, AK)

It’s understandable to think this would consist entirely of New York City, Los Angeles, or San Francisco ZIPs. But when we consider what it costs operators to import food to Hawaii and Alaska. Additionally, Washington and New York are among the states with the highest minimum wage. Operators need to recover those costs somehow.

And now the five least-expensive ZIP codes:

78526 (Brownsville, TX)
75224 (Dallas, TX)
76106 (Fort Worth, TX)
31907 (Columbus, GA)
31701 (Albany, GA)

Pricing Logic

Now, on to what Li says during the webinar that makes me laugh.

Nationwide, the average price of a McDonald’s Big Mac in the US is $5.26. (A caveat: This webinar took place in October. This price may have increased or decreased by now.)

However, the lowest price for a Big Mac is $3.49 at a location in Wilburton, Oklahoma.

So, what’s the highest price, and where can one find these pricey Big Macs? Three McDonald’s locations sell the burger for $8.29. That’s nearly two-and-a-half times the lowest-priced Big Mac.

Summarizing pricing variations among chain restaurants succinctly, Li made me laugh with the following: “Store pricing often just doesn’t make sense.”

Going further, Li says Datassential shows that the more franchised a restaurant chain is, the more variances in pricing will occur.

The full webinar can be viewed here.

Image: Leonardo Luz on Pexels